DEARBORN DEPARTMENT OF LIBRARIES

LIBRARY COMMISSION MEETING

12-09-05

 

1. ATTENDANCE:

In attendance were: MRS. NANCY ZAKAR, Chairperson, MR. MARCEL PULTORAK, Vice-Chairperson; DR. ALEX SHAMI, Secretary-Treasurer; MRS. SYLVIA PRESSMAN, MRS. CANDYCE ABBATT, MRS. DIANE PEPPER, MR. DAVID SCHLAFF,

MR. ROBERT TAUB, MR. RONALD WATTERS, Commissioners;

DR. PATRICK COADY, Library Director, MARYANNE BARTLES, Assistant Library Director, MS. TARA GNAU, MRS. JULIE SCHAEFER, Administrative Librarians.

 

2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES:

The minutes from the September, October and November Commission meetings were approved as submitted. 

 

3. DEPARTMENTAL RULES VOTE:

Dr. Coady explained that Mrs. Bartles worked on simplifying, condensing and rearranging the departmental rules.  There was very little added to the rules.  We tried to go through the document and make sure that everything was in logical sequence.  Over the years many additions were added to the end of the document and were often not logical in their placement. There were some things taken out of the document as new City policies will supersede library departmental rules.  The current revisions have been through review by the Administrative panel as well as a couple of different supervisory reviews.  The document has been put out to the library staff as well as reviewed by the Legal Department, Human Resources and the Mayors office. Mr. Pultorak motioned to approve the Departmental Rules changes, seconded by Dr. Shami, all approved.

 

4. FOUNDATION UPDATE:

Mrs. Abbatt stated that the Commissioners task is to put together a wish list of projects for the Library Foundation to consider.  The Commissioners were presented with two lists of ideas, one from Candyce Abbatt and a list compiled from library staff member idea submissions.  Mrs. Abbatt asked Dr. Coady if Ann Knoop, Chairperson of the foundation board, wanted the items presented prioritized.  Dr. Coady stated that he spoke with her and she did not feel that was necessary at this time.  They are basically looking for a raw list at this time.  The Commissioners read over the list of ideas and discussed them.  Mr. Pultorak stated that he felt that it was important not to embark on a program or service that would not be sustainable. The library is subject to potential further cutbacks and that should be considered. Mr. Schlaff stated that he felt that the number one priority of the foundation should be establishing an endowment fund. The Commissioners consolidated the two lists that were presented into one list.  The wish list items are as follows:

 

1. Establish an endowment fund by focusing on estate planning and gifts. 

2. Building

a.      Statuary

b.      Children’s area improvements at all locations (see current study).

3. Special Programs (any commitment to programming must be for a set period of years)

a.      Specialized children’s programs/series

b.      Outreach service to the elderly and homebound patrons (i.e. delivery service which might also be applicable to other patrons).

c.      Diverse communications projects

d.      Technology

a.      Adaptive technology for the disabled

b.      Downloadable audio books, news articles

4. Enhancement of organization and operations

a.      New shelving which would be more user-friendly with tipped bottom shelves and more face out shelving options similar to the Esper Branch.

b.      Make individual study rooms “computer friendly”.

 

 

5. ELECTION OF OFFICERS:

The same slate of officers as last year was nominated again. Nancy Zakar as chairperson, Marcel Pultorak as vice chairperson and Alex Shami as Secretary-Treasurer. The Commission members all approved the election of the new slate of officers.  

 

7. NEW BUSINESS:

Library patron Mr. Okray spoke to the Library Commission regarding the distribution of campaign materials on City property, particularly on library property. This issue was originally brought up at the last Library Commission meeting when Mr. Okray spoke to the Library Commission.  Mr. Okay, Bob Bryer and Mary Joe Durivage formed the “Save Bryant Library” group and wanted to pass out information regarding candidates for City Charter Commission who they felt support the library.  Mr. Okray was advised by the City Legal Department that he was not permitted to distribute election materials on City property.  Mr. Okray does not agree with the citation he feels is being used to state he can not do this.  He was at HFCL, along with other members of his group, on the Saturday before the election passing out campaign material after he had been advised by the Legal Department not to do this and was told by the library guard to leave.  Ultimately, the Dearborn Police were called and the group was told to leave.  The ordinance that both library staff and the police quoted to the group as the reason they were not permitted to do this was different than the citation given by the Legal Department.  Mr. Okray does not feel either citation is correct.  Both Mr. Okray and Mr. Bryer have written a letter to Corporation Counsel, Debbie Walling, but have not received a response. Dr. Coady explained that he is obligated to follow the guidance given by Corporation Counsel. He also explained that the library code of conduct prohibits distributing leaflets on library property. He had been advised that patrons complained about the group distributing flyers.  Marcel Pultorak stated that the essence of this dispute is that the group does not agree with the City’s interpretation of an ordinance.  Mr. Okray stated that freedom of speech was a major issue and one that he feels the Library Commission should be supportive of. Dr. Coady stated that the group could request that the City Charter Commission review this issue and send them a letter. Mrs. Zakar asked Mr. Okray if he planned to pursue this with the Charter Commission and he said he did not unless the Library Commission formally supported it.  Mr. Watters stated he did not feel it was the Library Commissions duty to address these types of concerns. 

 

 

The meeting was adjourned at 5:45PM.